By George Bosnjak

As someone currently building my fourth healthcare technology company, I’ve learned to value practical, hard-working solutions over the flashy hype touted by Silicon Valley. So, when Pope Leo XIV released his encyclical Magnifica Humanitas addressing the rapid rise of artificial intelligence and its potential consequences, I paid attention. I’m a Midwestern dad, not a theologian. However, as I read the Pope’s grounded, human-centric concerns about AI, I found myself nodding along in agreement.
The Pope cautions humanity against building a modern “Tower of Babel.” He rightly raises concerns about a technocratic paradigm driven by a dehumanizing ambition for dominance and efficiency at the expense of the human person. This warning resonates in the health tech industry today, where an epidemic of AI evangelists continuously overpromise and underdeliver. We regularly hear a polarized narrative that often obscures reality: that AI is either a panacea for all our problems or an existential threat.
My perspective on AI is grounded in pragmatism. The truth lies somewhere in the much more nuanced, and quite frankly less trendy, middle. Excessive industry excitement and superficial trends surrounding AI are meaningless unless they actually solve real-world problems.
In his encyclical, the Pope makes a profound observation about AI accountability, insisting that responsibility must be clearly defined at every stage of development and deployment. He correctly points out that algorithms and AI systems do not possess a moral conscience and lack “compassion, mercy, forgiveness.”
As the founder of an AI-powered health tech startup, I completely agree. AI should never be used to make healthcare decisions. However, it can be used to tackle problems that plague the industry, such as the overwhelming volume of unstructured data trapped in PDFs, scanned faxes, credentialing packets, and referral notes. This mountain of paperwork forces clinicians and administrators to spend excessive time on documentation instead of patient care, driving up costs and contributing to spiraling burnout. AI can be an effective tool to tackle this mundane, administrative burden, transforming static documents into actionable data so people can make the best business and clinical decisions possible. By putting AI in the role of a silent steward, providers can be freed up to focus on healing, a fundamentally human endeavor.
And here’s the critical point, which also aligns with the Pope’s call for human oversight and clearly defined AI responsibility. AI should not be allowed to run wild. Instead, AI needs to be put in a “straitjacket” of clear operational limits. While these constraints will naturally vary from one AI company to the next, depending on the unique services and goals of each AI organization, the need for responsible guardrails must remain the standard.
The Pope also astutely warns that in the modern workplace, AI frequently “forces workers to adapt to the speed and demands of machines, rather than machines being designed to support those who work.” He cautions that this approach can de-skill workers and erode their sense of agency, cutting to the very core of human dignity.
At its heart, AI should not be viewed as a replacement for human workers; instead, it should be seen as an amplifier. Contrary to popular opinion, AI doesn’t have to mean flashy tech. Consider innovations like the nail or the ballpoint pen. They were revolutionary in their day, simple tools that significantly amplified human productivity. Similarly, basic tech can hold big things together, giving people the discrete, actionable information they need to do what humans do best: leverage their education, empathy, and experience to make the right decisions in the moment.
Healthcare and health tech are not industries where stakeholders should be moving fast and breaking things. Instead, there should be a focus on thoughtfully mending the broken and methodically testing things with science. The Pope challenges us to ask if technology can “make human life on earth ‘more human.’” He urges us to “disarm AI” so that it remains a tool to serve the common good. By ignoring the sensationalism surrounding AI and building AI solutions that safely, securely, and ethically empower individuals to do their jobs more effectively, we can build technology that truly serves humanity. True progress lies in ensuring that machines carry the weight of our administrative burdens, so that we are finally free to exercise the one thing algorithms can never replicate: our capacity to care for people, not the paperwork.